Tripura has a long and delicate record of living together across communities, and that record is never more fragile than in the heat of an election campaign. The controversy over remarks attributed to Boxanagar MLA Tofazzal Hossain is therefore not a passing political spat. It touches the identity and dignity of the Tiprasa people, and it deserves a serious response.
The facts, as reported, are these. Several tribal organisations affiliated with BJP ally Tipra Motha, as well as the CPI(M), lodged complaints at police stations in Agartala demanding legal action. TIPRA Motha founder Pradyot Kishore Manikya Debbarma objected to remarks about the food habits and lifestyle of indigenous people. He said that the legislator had taken an oath to uphold the Constitution and should respect the dignity of the Tiprasa people.
That argument is hard to dispute. What a community eats and how it lives are part of who it is. They are not fair material for political ridicule, and certainly not from an elected representative whose oath binds him to represent every citizen. A public figure who mocks a community’s way of life does more than offend. He tells that community that its place in the state is conditional.
Yet the response so far has not been a clear one. Hossain expressed regret on Wednesday and appealed for peace and communal harmony. In a video message he sought to clarify his comments, though the Tipra Motha chief described the purported apology as an attempt to divert attention. The MLA’s own position is that his speech was selectively edited and taken out of context. If that is so, it should be easy to show. The full, unedited footage should be placed before the public and the police, and the matter settled on facts, not on competing clips.
An apology that blames the audience for hearing wrongly is not the same as an apology. Equally, a legislator is entitled to a fair investigation before he is judged. Both can be true at once, and the way to honour both is a transparent, time-bound inquiry.
The ruling party has made some moves. The BJP served Hossain a show-cause notice, requiring a reply within seven days or possible party action. Chief Minister Manik Saha said the law would take its own course, but also that Hossain had already expressed regret and the matter should be viewed from that perspective. A notice is a start, not an answer. The party should say plainly that such remarks have no place in its politics, and let the findings be made public.
The opposition, for its part, should resist the temptation to turn a question of dignity into a campaign weapon. The Congress has demanded an FIR under the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act. Whether that law applies is for the police and the courts to decide on the evidence, not for party platforms. Outrage is justified. Using it to score points before the polls on November 17 will only deepen the harm.
There is a wider lesson here for everyone who seeks votes in this state. A campaign can be sharp, even bitter, without crossing into contempt for another community’s food, faith or way of life. Parties across the spectrum should give their speakers a simple rule: criticise policies and records, never people’s identities.
Finally, the Tiprasa community is entitled to more than regret. It is entitled to clarity on what was said, accountability if the words were as reported, and an assurance that the state’s elected representatives understand where the line lies. Tripura’s peace was built over decades. It should not be put at risk for a few seconds of campaign applause.
Dhruba Deka
