OIL RELIEF IS NOT AN ENERGY STRATEGY

DA Editorial Desk| Dhruba Deka

Dalal Street had reason to cheer on Thursday. The Sensex jumped more than 2,000 points to close at 79,310, and the Nifty settled at 24,536, lifted by two pieces of good news arriving together. One was the Democratic sweep in the US midterm elections, which investors read as a check on Washington’s unpredictability. The other was a slide in crude prices that took Brent back towards the $100-a-barrel mark. It was a welcome day for investors, and for anyone worried about prices at the pump. But India should resist the temptation to mistake one session’s relief for a change in fundamentals. The country’s oil vulnerability is structural, and Thursday’s rally did nothing to repair it.

The numbers tell the story. India imports roughly 85 to 88 per cent of the crude oil it consumes, and by several estimates around 40 per cent of that passes through the Strait of Hormuz. Since the US-Iran war began on February 28, that narrow waterway has become the single biggest variable in India’s economic planning. Brent has swung from about $69 before the war to peaks near $115 in May and again in late October. Even this week, as hopes of a US-Iran deal dragged prices down, Tehran said the two sides remain far apart, the United States struck air defences on Qeshm Island, and another tanker was attacked near Hormuz. That is not a crisis ending. It is a pause.

High oil prices work like a tax on the entire economy. Crude is bought in dollars, so every rise in Brent widens the import bill, raises demand for the American currency and weighs on the rupee, which analysts say has touched record lows near 95 this year. Imported inflation follows. Consumers have so far been largely shielded, with the government reluctant to pass the full burden to pump prices. But a shield paid for by oil marketing companies and the public exchequer is not free. Sooner or later someone pays, whether through subsidies, a larger deficit or the petrol pump.

India has done some things right. Its refiners have widened their supplier base, with Russian crude playing a far bigger role than it did before 2022. Foreign investors have also returned, putting Rs 7,284 crore into Indian shares on Wednesday, the highest single-day figure in a year. Yet such flows are fickle. They follow oil prices and global sentiment, precisely the things India does not control.

There is a lesson in the market’s own behaviour. Information technology stocks fell 1.5 per cent on Wednesday even as the broader index climbed, a reminder that India’s fortunes are tied to forces well beyond its borders, from American politics to artificial intelligence spending to the price of a barrel of oil. Resilience means reducing that dependence wherever possible. A country that produces more of its own energy, stores more of what it buys and spreads its risks across suppliers can welcome good news abroad without being hostage to bad news.

What, then, should the government do with this breathing space?

First, build strategic reserves. The International Energy Agency expects its members to hold stocks equal to 90 days of net oil imports. India’s cover is estimated at only about ten days. Underground storage is expensive, but it is the cheapest insurance a heavily import-dependent economy can buy.

Second, look beyond crude. Hormuz also carries a large share of India’s LNG and LPG, and this year’s shock showed how quickly a gas shortage becomes a fertiliser shortage. Energy security and food security are now the same conversation.

Third, produce more at home. The reported Rs 80,000 crore package to attract deepwater explorers is a good start, but investors will want clear contracts, stable rules and quick approvals, not just headline numbers.

Fourth, accelerate electrification. Every electric bus, rooftop solar panel, battery storage project and unit of nuclear power that replaces imported fuel is a hedge against the next shock.

Fifth, use diplomacy. India talks to Washington, Tehran, Moscow and the Gulf capitals alike. That unusual position should be used to protect shipping lanes and secure supply commitments before the next flare-up, not after it.

The midterm results may change Washington’s approach to West Asia, and the same week brought President Trump’s announcement that the United States will end its $4 billion annual military aid to Israel, a sign of a region being recalibrated. But nobody should assume this brings calm. Mr Trump remains in the White House, and a divided government can be just as unpredictable on foreign policy as a united one. India cannot outsource its energy security to the outcome of American elections.

Markets forget quickly. Policy must not. The rally will fade, and the next spike in crude will arrive without notice. The time to prepare is now, while the rupee is steadier and the headlines are kinder.

Scroll to Top